Legislative Shifts in Employee Screening: “Ban the Box,” Fair Chance, and Drug Testing Laws

The landscape of employee screening is changing quickly. Employers across the United States are navigating a patchwork of new laws that impact how and when they can run background checks, as well as what they can test for. Two areas in particular—Fair Chance hiring laws and evolving drug testing regulations—are creating challenges for HR teams and compliance officers alike.

Let's explore the most important legislative shifts employers should be aware of, including the rise of “Ban the Box” and Fair Chance laws, and the growing complexity of drug testing in the era of cannabis legalization.

Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring Laws

What the Laws Mean

“Ban the Box” laws prohibit employers from asking about criminal convictions on initial job applications. Instead, questions about criminal history must wait until later in the hiring process, often after a conditional job offer.

Fair Chance laws take this further. Employers are required to conduct individualized assessments before denying a candidate based on a criminal record. These assessments weigh factors like the nature of the offense, how long ago it occurred, and whether it is relevant to the job.

State-Level Developments

States and municipalities continue to strengthen these laws. More jurisdictions are requiring delayed checks and standardized assessment procedures. For example, several states now mandate written explanations to applicants if an offer is rescinded due to a criminal record.



The result is a more complex hiring process for multi-state employers. Screening timelines are extended, and HR teams must document how decisions are made to remain compliant.

Why It Matters

For employers, this means building robust policies that not only comply with laws but also ensure consistency and fairness. For candidates, it opens doors to jobs that may have been closed to them under older, more rigid systems.

Cannabis Legalization and Drug Testing

A Shifting Legal Landscape

The legalization of cannabis—whether medical or recreational—is creating new complications for drug screening. Nearly half of U.S. states now allow recreational marijuana, and most allow medical use. This raises questions about how employers should handle positive drug tests.

Off-Duty Use Protections

Several states now protect employees from being penalized for legal, off-duty cannabis use. In New Jersey, a recent federal appeals court decision clarified that while the state’s cannabis bias law protects workers from discrimination, it does not give individuals the right to sue employers directly. Instead, enforcement rests with state regulators (Reuters).

Employers Adjusting Policies

Some major employers are already adjusting their drug testing strategies. In August 2024, reports revealed that Home Depot stopped screening most job applicants for marijuana, except in safety-sensitive roles like asset protection and transportation (New York Post).

This reflects a broader trend: employers are rethinking whether testing for cannabis makes sense in states where it is legal, especially given the tight labor market.

The Reality of Test Cheating

At the same time, marijuana remains the most frequently detected substance in workplace drug testing. According to data reported by the Wall Street Journal, instances of workers attempting to cheat drug tests hit record highs in 2023. The number of tampered or substituted urine samples increased sixfold in a single year (WSJ).

This trend demonstrates that while some employers relax cannabis testing policies, others continue to view it as an essential safeguard—particularly in safety-sensitive industries.

Challenges for Employers

Employers face a delicate balance:

• Legal compliance requires keeping up with state-specific laws on background checks and cannabis protections.
• Workplace safety demands that employees in safety-sensitive roles remain unimpaired.
• Candidate experience can be harmed by slow screening or unclear policies, creating drop-off in competitive labor markets.
• Reputation and liability are at stake when compliance failures lead to lawsuits or public backlash.

How HR Teams Can Adapt

1. Stay current with legislation. Employers must monitor state and local laws closely, as rules for criminal history checks and cannabis protections vary significantly.
2. Standardize policies. Clear, written policies ensure consistency in how background checks and drug screenings are conducted.
3. Document individualized assessments. In Fair Chance states, employers must show evidence of fair decision-making.
4. Reassess drug testing programs. Decide which roles require cannabis testing and which do not, aligning with legal protections and workplace safety.
5. Educate HR staff and hiring managers. Training is key to ensure compliance and to avoid biased or inconsistent practices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is “Ban the Box”?

“Ban the Box” laws remove criminal history questions from initial job applications, requiring employers to ask later in the process.

What are Fair Chance hiring laws?

Fair Chance laws require employers to conduct individualized assessments when considering criminal history and to delay criminal checks until later hiring stages.

Are employers still allowed to run criminal background checks?

Yes. Employers can still run checks, but in many jurisdictions they must delay them and ensure they are used fairly.

Can employers test for cannabis if it’s legal in their state?

Yes, but in some states employers cannot take action against candidates or employees for legal, off-duty use. Exceptions apply for safety-sensitive roles or federally regulated industries.

How are large employers responding?

Some, like Home Depot, have stopped testing for marijuana in most roles. Others continue to test, especially in industries where impairment could pose safety risks.

What should employers do to stay compliant?

Employers should regularly review state laws, update policies, document their decision-making, and train staff on compliance requirements.

Final Thoughts

The landscape of employee screening is becoming more nuanced and more regulated. Ban the Box and Fair Chance laws are changing how criminal history is evaluated, while cannabis legalization is forcing employers to reconsider long-standing drug testing practices.

What’s clear is that screening is no longer just about risk prevention. It is about compliance, fairness, and balancing candidate rights with workplace safety. Employers who adapt their policies proactively will be better positioned to hire confidently in this evolving environment.